ASIAWEEK November 28, 2001
From the issue
Nov 28, 2001
ASIAWEEK
Webfiles: Despair in Hong Kong
A mother's wrenching account of trying to get by in a city that was once golden
By CRYSTYL MO

Wednesday, November 28, 2001
Web posted at 03:45 p.m. Hong Kong time, 03:45 a.m. GMT

Last week, I conducted one of the most difficult interviews of my career. I was researching the impact of the economic recession in Hong Kong. After many calls to social service agencies, a social worker named Grace told me she had a client willing to talk about her devastating financial difficulties. One month earlier, Grace explained, MaryJane had planned to kill herself and her four-year-old daughter.

I arrived early at the social services center where Grace had arranged for us all to meet: a large, echoing building at the end of a dead-end street in a gritty Kowloon neighborhood. I waited for them in a room filled with children's toys and a paper cutout on the wall labeled The Tree of Hope. When MaryJane walked in, I could almost feel her body trembling. A small woman with long glossy hair, she looked at me with a hesitant smile, but her eyes were shining with tears. My stomach tightened. How could I ask her about suicide when she looked so frightened of everything, I thought? "Can you tell me how your financial difficulties started?" I began.

MaryJane spoke in a quiet voice. "My father was a wonderful jazz musician," she said. "He played with all the greats in the 1950s. We had a lot of money back then -- servants, a nice house." She paused and her eyes flickered over to Grace for reassurance. "But my father was a gambler. We lost it all." MaryJane explained that after high school she immediately began working to help support herself and her family. She married at 19 and four years later she had her first son.

"Back then it was easy to find jobs," she told me. She had another son and though her family was not well off, she managed to support them for over a decade. In 1993, her sister died and in order to pay for the funeral, MaryJane took on the first of a series of debts that would eventually drive her to the brink of suicide. A few years later, MaryJane's parent's debts had piled up to overwhelming levels. She paid for them to move to a different address, escaping the bill collectors but still living hand-to-mouth.

In 1997, MaryJane's brother lost his job. She had a third child, a daughter she dotes on. Meanwhile her own credit-card bills soared into the tens of thousands. Her brother, unemployed for two years, relied on her to pay the $60,000 debt on his card. Then she lost a small business she had founded. "I was stupid," she said looking at the floor. "I opened a restaurant on the second floor of a building. I worked very hard and I barely charged anything for the lunchboxes, but still nobody bought them." MaryJane now works as a receptionist for a large firm, but her $18,000 monthly income cannot cover the minimum repayments for her seven credit cards.

Collection agencies began harassing her over the phone. After a few late payments earlier this year, several credit companies all announced at once that they were canceling MaryJane's accounts and demanded full payment of all debts. For the first time, she became desperate. "I am willing to pay, but they won't agree to a compromise," she said. "I pleaded with each of them to let me make a smaller monthly payment. I said I really have nothing. They told me, 'We have our bottom line to think about.' When you hear these words, your mind goes blank, you feel lost."

MaryJane spent weeks scouring the city for a second job. But in today's frail Hong Kong economy, there are no longer any takers. She entered every restaurant in a two-kilometer stretch but no one was hiring. "That's when I told my daughter everything," she said. "I told her I wanted to die." MaryJane planned her suicide in detail. She located a suitable hotel and bought charcoal to suffocate herself and her young daughter. In a suicide note written in the third person, MaryJane explained she wanted to take her daughter with her because "The mother was never happy even during her childhood days, she was not able to fulfill the dream she promised herself when she was young."

Our room went quiet for a moment. I thought of the hundreds of suicide calls that have been pouring into hotlines in Hong Kong over the past few months. So many broken dreams like MaryJane's. Counseling with Grace has convinced MaryJane to hang on, even though she says she sometimes still feels "that suicidal emotion overcoming me." For now, though, MaryJane has decided to fight for her life and for a future for her children. She is determined to juggle her bills, bargain with the collection agents and come up with a strategy for survival.

I thanked MaryJane and left. In a dark alleyway outside, a wiry young man was stripped to the waist, with white gauze wrapped around his hands. He looked gaunt but was punching the air energetically, bouncing back and forth as he practiced boxing. I finally let out a long breath and smiled at him. "That's the spirit," I thought.

email this article to a friendcheck the originally published article

Back to Top
 
 
Commentary 2003-12-06
 
Coming soon to the commentary column--behind the scenes stories of the how the articles are really put together--the difficulty in getting anyone to accept an interview in China, the political sensitivities, the great stuff that got cut because of space, and much more about the joys and frustrations of writing in China
 
 
Asiaweek articles  
Soldier and the Citadel one of Beijing's most successful painters has thousands of fervent fan
Lights Culture Action Shanghai in all her glory, a big issue for me: 18 hour days, stress, and lots of fun
A Personal Odyssey from the Shanghai issue, I found my grandparents' 1930's college transcripts
Glory Days An ambitious American Chinese lawyer wants to bring the high life back to the Bund
Generation Gap fathers and sons are interesting to interview together
Storming the Beaches undercover on a tropical Thailand island, with a tour group from Shanghai
A Trek On The Wild Side there are still some gorgeous unspoiled places in China
Trying to Fit In Taiwanese children studying Taiwanese textbooks in a polluted S. China factory town
May Your Dreams Come True a night I will never forget, the eve of Beijing's successful Olympic bid
China Gets The Mobile Message I like to think I got one of the earliest scoops on China's SMS boom
Growth At All Costs China's two gigantic mobile operators battle it out
Breaking Out The Fine China a wonderfully talented designer brings class to the masses
Broken Dreams Hong Kong's long, sad decline, as it faces off with its billion neighbors to the South
Climbing the Walls WTO doesn't mean instant access to the China market (surprise surprise)
WTO Happiness For CCTV China's state-owned TV is in the money
Backtalk: Mister Reform an interview with a brilliant up-and-coming Japanese politician
Backtalk: Yao Ming yes, he really is unbelievably huge. He's also kind, smart, and bored stiff by interviews
 
Asiaweek online columns
Webfiles: Drive She Said who doesn't love a Beijing cabbie?
Webfiles: Life on China's New Frontier I admit it, I'm a web addict. I love my Chinese webpals
Webfiles: Despair in Hong Kong one of the most difficult, and moving interviews I've ever done
 
City Weekend articles
Crawling the Catwalks luxury brands are here, patiently waiting for Chinese to get rich
The Train Soon Arriving the world's first magnetic levitation train, in Shanghai of all places
Death of the Salesmen China's beloved mom and pop stores are going the way of the dodo
 
Time Asia articles
China Mountain High I travel to stunning Yunnan province to hang out with Chinese hikers
In Nanjing It's Art For Arts Sake a lovely, tree-filled city with great food and beautiful hikes
Detour Nanjing's ancient city wall
Hot Spot snacking in Nanjing
Brick City China's pro basketball industry has lots of great athletes and zero business sense
Back to Top
 
 
©2003 Crystyl Mo. Muo Yun All rights reserved. Contact me